U.S. Defies U.N. Decision–

Plans Massive Military Detonation on Western Shoshone Land Western Shoshone
call for halt to planned June 2 “Bunker Buster” detonation at the Nevada Test Site

"Divine Strake"

background : Divine Strake from Federation of American Scientists (website)


Apr. 27, 2006

Officials show off pit, offer assurances blast will be safe

By KEITH ROGERS
REVIEW-JOURNAL

A worker pushes a cart Wednesday in the tunnel beneath a pit at the Nevada Test Site where an explosives tests will take place in June. The tunnel will simulate a location where weapons of mass destructions could be buried.

Photo by Clint Karlsen.

NEVADA TEST SITE -- Miners took a break Wednesday from drilling and blasting a large pit in which 700 tons of explosives is scheduled to be detonated June 2.

With the 36-foot-deep pit only two-thirds finished, work halted as Defense and Energy officials offered a tour of a tunnel 100 feet beneath the pit and assured reporters they can safely conduct the Divine Strake bunker-buster test if all goes as planned.

The massive detonation of ammonium nitrate and fuel oil set off by C-4 explosives will give weapons scientists data on how shock waves travel through a 100-foot-thick block of bedded limestone. The tunnel will offer evidence of the blast's power to destroy a buried cache of weapons of mass destruction.

The above-ground blast near the top of Syncline Ridge will send a mushroom-shaped dust cloud 10,000 feet into the atmosphere and release an explosive yield equivalent to detonating 593 tons of TNT, 85 miles northwest of Las Vegas, said officials with the Defense Threat Reduction Agency. That would be larger than the 430-ton yield produced by the Danny Boy nuclear bomb that was set off in a basalt crater at the test site in 1962.

The $23 million Divine Strake test will be the culmination of a decade of planning and experimentation aimed at fine-tuning confidence in the ability of existing weapons to defeat deeply buried, hardened targets.

One official, Doug Bruder, a civil engineer who leads the agency's Counter Weapons of Mass Destruction Directorate, denied that the Divine Strake test is geared to developing a new nuclear bunker-buster bomb as some independent scientists have speculated.

Instead, he said, the effort is to assess the capabilities of current weapons to penetrate a target through explosive shock waves in a specific geologic setting -- in this case, a limestone tunnel.

The test supports how officials can "best plan for those weapons to be used if we ever have to," Bruder said. "What it also gives us in the future is how high the bar needs to be in terms of our future advanced explosives."

Aside from the Divine Strake test, he said the agency has a large program to explore more powerful conventional explosives.

"We want those explosives to be as powerful as possible but non-nuclear. So we need to know what does it take to actually defeat a facility like that. Now we know what we actually have to achieve in terms of power of the new explosive," he said.

Since construction of the 1,100-foot-long tunnel was completed in 1999, the agency has conducted 45 tests, including live munitions dropped by Air Force warplanes, he said. That is in addition to small-scale laboratory experiments for the project and a pair of medium-scale explosions at the Mitchell limestone quarry, about 35 miles south of Bloomington, Ind. Those tests in 2004 and 2005 were powered by 3,000 pounds of nitromethane.

Officials for the National Nuclear Security Administration, a branch of the Department of Energy that is hosting the test, would not comment on a lawsuit seeking to block the test that was filed last week by Western Shoshones and downwinders from Utah.

Nevada environmental officials meanwhile, have asked the NNSA for more information that demonstrates harmful pollutants won't be released beyond the boundary of the 1,375-square-mile test site.

Most above-ground contamination sites are more than four miles away from the tunnel. A muck pile from six nuclear tests that were conducted below ground is more than a mile away. Those below-ground, weapons effects tests were conducted between 1962 and 1971, NNSA officials said.

The atmospheric, atomic bomb tests -- four each in two locations -- were conducted during the 1950s.

During Wednesday's preview tour, Linda Cohn, an NNSA environmental protection specialist, offered assurances that no radioactive materials from past nuclear tests at the test site would be injected into the atmosphere and carried beyond the test site's boundary.

She said survey's conducted Tuesday confirmed that "there is no radioactive contamination adjacent to this experiment site."

"The crater from this test is only about 98 feet in radius. It will be a large cloud but it's not going to go off site," Cohn said.

http://www.reviewjournal.com/lvrj_home/2006/Apr-27-Thu-2006/news/7073128.html
Copyright © Las Vegas Review-Journal


By Robert Gehrke gehrke@sltrib.com
The Salt Lake Tribune
http://www.sltrib.com/ci_3748465
April 25, 2006

Explosion test has Hatch upset
Concerns grow over possible dispersal of old radioactive material in Nevada

 

WASHINGTON - Sen. Orrin Hatch has joined a group of Congress members voicing concerns about "Divine Strake," a massive explosion planned this summer at the Nevada Test Site that critics say could have nuclear implications.

Hatch sent a letter Friday to the Defense Threat Reduction Agency, seeking assurances that the test would not disperse any radioactive material left over from past nuclear weapons tests at the Nevada site.

"The more I look into this, the more upset I become," Hatch said in a statement. "The good people who live downwind from this test site have already been through enough, and I've given them my word that I'll never allow any nuclear testing that could harm them again. I have directed my staff to check into this very closely, and if I'm not satisfied that this will be safe, I'm going to do everything I can to put a stop to it."

The agency has said that its environmental assessment determined there was no radioactive material at the site.

But Hatch's interest was piqued when the environmental assessment first listed the blast site as being 2.5 miles from any prior radioactive testing, but in another location listed it as being 1.5 miles. Then in response to an inquiry, the actual location was determined to be 1.1 miles from prior testing.

That prompted Hatch to ask the defense agency to review its data and provide assurances the test could be safe.

Michelle Thomas, who is a Downwinder - a group of people suffering illnesses as a result of their exposure to radioactive fallout from Cold War nuclear tests - said Hatch did not express his concern during a sometimes heated public meeting with other downwinders last week. Thomas said she confronted the senator about the test safety and he defended the need for it.

"I can't even believe they're doing it," said Thomas, who has suffered a number of ailments, primarily an immune deficiency, as a result of her radiation exposure. "I vacillate between rage and tears. I really did not dream they'd try one of these above-ground [tests]."

At that Downwinders' event, according to The Spectrum in St. George, Hatch reportedly said he saw no reason to stop the test, but would put the brakes on if he thought it was unsafe.

In his letter, Hatch said there are over 1,400 hardened bunkers and underground targets in such places as North Korea, China, Iran and Libya, and he understands the need to be able to penetrate them.

The test itself, known as Divine Strake, involves detonating 700 tons of explosives on the Nevada Test Site. Pentagon budget documents say the test is intended to help war planners pick the smallest nuclear device needed to destroy hardened targets, like underground bunkers.

That prompted concern from anti-proliferation groups and Downwinders that the test would lead to development of new, low-yield tactical nuclear weapons.

The Defense Department has since said that the inclusion of "nuclear" in the budget document was an oversight, and the test is meant to gather data on ground-shaking for computer modeling.

The explosives in the test are like those used in the Oklahoma City bombing, only 280 times stronger. The blast will be 50 times larger than that from the largest U.S.. conventional weapon.

The Western Shoshone Indian tribe and two Utah Downwinders have filed a lawsuit in federal court to stop the test, arguing that the blast would stir up radioactive remnants from past tests.

The plume from the explosion is expected to reach several thousand feet above the ground. Air monitors would be set up to track the debris.

Rep. Jim Matheson, D-Utah, has also sent a letter to the agency, seeking assurances that there will not be any radioactive material dispersed, and inquiring if the test is truly designed to help develop new, low-yield nuclear weapons.

Nevada Sen. Harry Reid and Rep. Shelley Berkley were briefed on the planned test and said it could be conducted safely.

However, the Nevada Division of Environmental Protection has demanded additional air quality data and computer models for the test. Until they get those, the division said it will not grant a permit for the test to proceed.

A Pentagon spokeswoman said it would provide the requested data and plans to stick to the June 2 test date.

Hatch and Matheson will be sending staff to a special congressional briefing at the Nevada Test Site on Wednesday.

Expect trouble as an inevitable part of life, and when it comes, hold your head high, look it squarely in the eye and say, "I will be bigger than you. You cannot defeat me."

Ann Landers


Daily Ireland
reporting on Western Shoshone and stopping the Divine Strake test
- Remember - May 28, 2006 is the International Day of Action to stop Divine Strike
(700 ton Ammonium Nitrate detonation in Nevada).

For more info send us an email or call the number below.

Western Shoshone Defense Project
P.O. Box 211308
Crescent Valley, NV 89821
775-468-0230
775-468-0237 (fax)
www.wsdp.org,
wsdp@igc.org

Native Americans step up campaign against bomb test

19/04/2006

With the clock ticking towards the Pentagons testing of a massive new bomb, Native Americans of Nevadas Western Shoshone nation are stepping up their efforts to stop the scheduled blast from occurring.

The Pentagon plans to detonate the new megabomb weighing 700 short tons (635 metric tons) on June 2, as part of its efforts to develop non-nuclear ordnance capable of destroying deeply buried, subterranean targets. Dubbed Divine Strake, the test is scheduled to take place on the Nevada Test Site a high desert valley that is surrounded by mountains and sits 140 kilometres from Las Vegas.

If the blast occurs, it will be the largest open-air chemical explosion in the sites history. According to Utah's Salt Lake Tribune, Divine Strake will be five times bigger than the largest non-nuclear bomb currently in the United States arsenal the Massive Ordinance Air Blast Bomb (MOAB), which has been nicknamed the Mother of All Bombs. Western Shoshone woman Carrie Dann, who has been a Native American activist for four decades, told Daily Ireland that the proposed blast was wrong not only for the indigenous peoples but for all peoples and all life.

The earth is your mother, and you cannot separate yourself from your mother," Ms Dann said during a telephone interview from the Nevada-based Western Shoshone Defence Project. You cannot take away the earth that feeds you and clothes you and everything. No way.

Kevin Rohrer a spokesman for the National Nuclear Security Administration, the agency that operates the test site has claimed that the United States is within its rights to conduct the testing. He insists that a 1985 US Supreme Court ruling recognised that the Shoshone were paid in full for the land under the Indian Claims Commission Act of 1946 and therefore the land no longer belongs to the tribe.

Julie Fishel, a lawyer for the Western Shoshone Defence Project, said all such court rulings were illegitimate because they were rooted in proclamations and laws passed during the original European conquest of indigenous lands.

Ms Fishel said such US claims were based on the Christian Document of Discovery, a doctrine formed via a series papal bulls that were issued between 1452 and 1493, as the Europeans began exploring lands in the western hemisphere. The Document of Discovery gave moral sanction to the seizing of native lands.

In 1823, the US Supreme Court officially incorporated the concept into US law by ruling that European settlers had achieved ultimate dominion over the lands that they had explored over the previous 330 years and that Native Americans had forever lost their rights to complete sovereignty, as independent nations.

Ms Fishel told Daily Ireland: US federal Indian law is based on the Document of Discovery antiquated, racist doctrines. And during those proceedings, the Western Shoshone were never allowed to present evidence. They were not given a hearing on the record.

Ms Fishel, whose great-grandparents were Irish, said she frequently used a link to Ireland when explaining events on Shoshone lands.

The pattern of behaviour between the United States and Native Americans is the same as whats happened in Ireland. In fact, we make that analogy quite often because many of the trees that were clear-cut in Ireland by the colonisers in Ireland were used to build ships to get to the US, and those people then colonised Indian lands here, she said.

According to Western Shoshone leaders, the proposed June 2 blast site was recognised by the United States as belonging to the Western Shoshone nation under the 1863 Treaty of Ruby Valley. The US authorities dispute this claim.

The Nevada Test Site, previously known as the Nevada Proving Ground, was the United States main nuclear weapons testing site between 1951 and 1959. Some arms-race experts believe that, even after the United States and the Soviet Union signed the Limited Test Ban Treaty of 1963, the United States conducted underground tests for many more years. Scientists have linked increased cases of cancer and leukaemia in areas surrounding the test site to exposure to radiation from the nuclear testing.

Julie Fishel said the proposed blast was all the more striking because of recent US government actions regarding nuclear science both in signing a treaty to bolster Indias nuclear capabilities, and US efforts to thwart the nuclear ambitions of Iran and North Korea.

I think the United States is doing whatever it wants to do. It doesn't seem to be paying heed to whether or not there is any consistency in that behaviour. They are behaving as if they dont have to follow anyones rules, that they can say one thing and then do exactly the opposite, she said.

In March, the United Nations Committee on the Elimination of Racial Discrimination in Geneva called on Washington to abort the June 2 test and to desist from activities that violated Western Shoshone sovereignty.

Activist Carrie Dann said: Even looking at it from the point of health, when you detonate a bomb like that down at the test site, its going to raise up the deaths from people already exposed to radiation. America has never really looked at the indigenous problem. America is supposed to be ruled by laws. But when it comes to indigenous issues,its just ruled by arrogance, as far as Im concerned.

Native Americans Want 'Bunker Buster' Test Stopped

Tue., Apr. 11, 2006

UNITED NATIONS, Apr 10 (OneWorld) - Native Americans want U.S. authorities to cancel plans to detonate 700 tons of explosives on what they say is tribal land in Nevada.

The planned explosion, scheduled for June 2 some 90 miles from Las Vegas, is aimed at aiding U.S. efforts to develop ''bunker buster'' weapons capable of penetrating solid rock. Officials have suggested the test would constitute the largest non-nuclear, open-air blast in the test site's history.

Federal officials have described such efforts as essential to the administration of President George W. Bush's self-styled ''war on terror'' but to leaders of the Shoshone, also known as the Newe people, the planned detonation is just the latest in a decades-long history of experiments at the Nevada Test Site to shake the earth and raise a dust cloud.

''We are opposed to any further military testing on our lands,'' said Raymond Yowell, chief of the Western Shoshone National Council.

The site of the latest proposed test sits on the land recognized under the 1863 Treaty of Ruby Valley as part of the tribe's national territory, Shoshone leaders said, and the U.S. military therefore has no right to use it.

The U.S. government disagreed and has asserted its ownership of the land.

''Without going through a lot of detail, the issue of ownership of the land area occupied by the Nevada Test Site, and for that matter very large sections of Nevada and Utah, is very complex (going back to the Ruby Valley Treaty) and in our eyes has been resolved,'' said Kevin Rohrer, a spokesman for the National Nuclear Security Administration, which operates the test site.

The U.S. Supreme Court had ruled in 1985 that the Shoshone had been paid in full for the land under the Indian Claims Commission Act of 1946 ''and thus the land is property of the United States Government,'' Rohrer said in an email.

''My understanding is that funding has been set aside in a trust account for compensation but there is disagreement among Western Shoshone on whether they should accept the funding,'' he added.

Shoshone elders rejected the government's position and last month won a victory in their fight to reclaim territory when the Geneva-based UN Committee on the Elimination of Racial Discrimination (CERD) said in a report that Washington's claim to the Western Shoshone land ''did not comply with contemporary human rights norms, principles and standards that govern determination of indigenous property rights.''

Among other things, the panel cited special concern over the existence of nuclear waste dumped on tribal territory without consulting and over the objections of the Western Shoshone people. The 18-member panel also asked Washington to ''freeze, desist and stop'' actions being taken against the Western Shoshone Nation.

In the ruling, CERD also cited concern over weapons testing at the Nevada Test Site as well as efforts to build a high-level nuclear waste depository at Yucca Mountain.

Tribal elders said Washington's plans to proceed with the June test in the face of the UN panel's findings was a slap in the face of the international and Native American communities.

''This is a direct violation of the CERD's finding and an affront to our religious belief,'' Yowell said. ''Mother Earth is sacred and should not be harmed.''

The U.S. military tested nuclear weapons at the Nevada site from 1951 until 1959. Some analysts have said they believe that even after signing the Limited Test Ban Treaty with the Soviet Union in 1963, the U.S. continued to conduct underground tests in the area for several years.

Scientists have said that exposure to radiation from nuclear testing caused an increased incidence of leukemia and cancer in areas adjacent to the Nevada Test Site.

All necessary permits to conduct the test have been obtained from Nevada state agencies, test authorities have said, but there has been no indication that they sought Shoshone approval.

The test has been named ''Divine Strake,'' adding to the outrage felt by many Native Americans, who say the test site sits on sacred land.

''It's a mystery why they call it 'divine','' said Carrie Dann, a grandmother and executive director of the Western Shoshone Defense Project. ''Isn't 'divine' used for your deity, God, your sacredness? Why don't they call it 'Hell Strake?'''

''When you are working testing weaponry of destruction of life, you should not associate it with 'divine','' Dann added. ''We want this insanity to stop. No more bombs and no more testing.''
PRINTABLE ARTICLE

Apr. 12, 2006
Copyright © Las Vegas Review-Journal


Environmental officials halt test site explosion

Massive, non-nuclear blast had been slated for June 2

By KEITH ROGERS
REVIEW-JOURNAL

Nevada environmental officials have halted a massive, non-nuclear explosion scheduled for June 2 at the Nevada Test Site until the federal agency hosting the blast shows it will comply with air quality standards and that hazardous particles can be tracked, letters released Tuesday reveal.

The National Nuclear Security Administration "is prohibited from allowing this test to proceed until authorization from NDEP (the Nevada Division of Environmental Protection) has been received," the state division Administrator Leo Drozdoff wrote in a letter sent Friday to test site manager Kathleen Carlson.

The letter refers to an April 28, 2005, request to Carlson from the state Bureau of Air Pollution Control.

"To date, the NNSA has not responded to this information request. NNSA is reminded that no approval was received. ... In order to conduct this test, NNSA needs to provide all information and demonstrations required," Drozdoff wrote.

Kevin Rohrer, a spokesman for the National Nuclear Security Administration's Nevada Site Office, said his agency will provide the requested information to the state "within two weeks."

"What the state wants to see is further analysis and computer modeling of any plume that might be generated from this to ensure that any emissions are still within the threshold established in our air permit," Rohrer said.

He said initial calculations based on detonating 900 tons of ammonium nitrate fuel oil solution in a 30-foot pit show the blast will be in compliance with the test site's air permit that was issued in June 2004.

The Defense Threat Reduction Agency, which wants to conduct the test above a limestone tunnel, intends to use a smaller amount of ammonium nitrate fuel oil solution, 700 tons.

"We believe we're going to be well below the threshold," Rohrer said.

The state's April 2005 request seeks documentation that identifies hazardous pollutants that will be carried by the explosion's mushroom cloud. It also calls for documentation that demonstrates that state and federal air quality standards will be met. The information is required under an existing air quality permit for operating the government's test site, 65 miles northwest of Las Vegas.

In a statement issued Tuesday, Steve Robinson, Gov. Kenny Guinn's deputy chief of staff, said: "The governor's office expects the NNSA to fully comply with all applicable state environmental rules and regulations before any testing is done."

Drozdoff's letter was written the same day that Citizen Alert, a statewide environmental group, called for the Defense Department and Energy Department to halt the Divine Strake blast, claiming it is unnecessary and could send surface contamination from previous atomic bomb tests into the air.

When told Tuesday about the state blocking the explosion until air quality compliance is demonstrated, Citizen Alert Executive Director Peggy Maze Johnson said she was delighted. But, she added, the calculations and modeling should be done by independent air-quality experts.

"Instead of NNSA hiring their contractors to do what the state wants, they need to bring in an independent study group to do that, somebody who isn't on their payroll and doesn't owe them," she said.

The Divine Strake blast is aimed at developing technology for weapons to penetrate "hardened and deeply buried targets," according to the Defense Threat Reduction Agency.

Western Shoshone oppose planned 700-ton detonation


Click to Enlarge Photo courtesy State of Nevada Division of Environmental Protection

ELKO, Nev. - Western Shoshone opposed the Pentagon's planned 700-ton detonation on aboriginal Western Shoshone land, as a delegation of Western Shoshone returned from Geneva, Switzerland, with support from the United Nations for protection of their human rights and territory.

James Tegnelia, director of the Pentagon's Defense Threat Reduction Agency, confirmed that the United States plans to detonate 700 tons of explosives at the Nevada Test Site on June 2.

While the Pentagon calls it ''Divine Strake,'' Western Shoshone said there is nothing divine about a massive explosion on their traditional lands.

''I believe when you are working testing weaponry for destruction of life, you should not associate it with 'divine.' We want this insanity to stop - no more bombs and no more testing,'' Western Shoshone grandmother Carrie Dann, executive director of the Western Shoshone Defense Project, said.

As Nevada and Utah congressmen pressed the Pentagon for answers, critics of the Bush administration say the blast is related to an effort to build a nuclear bunker-buster.

''It is abundantly clear, at least to me, that the military has not given up the idea of a nuclear penetrator,'' Christopher Hellman, policy analyst with the Center for Arms Control and Non-Proliferation in Washington, told the Las Vegas Sun newspaper.

Hellman said that Congress killed funding for the nuclear bunker-busting program last year. However, he said, ''they want it'' and would continue those efforts.

Western Shoshone said the test would be in direct violation of the recent decision of the U.N. Committee on the Elimination of Racial Discrimination. CERD, in the decision made public March 10, urged the United States to ''freeze,'' ''desist'' and ''stop'' actions and threats against the Western Shoshone.

The committee stressed the ''nature and urgency'' of the situation and informed the United States that it warrants immediate attention under the committee's Early Warning and Urgent Action Procedure.

The CERD decision explicitly cited ongoing weapons testing at the Nevada Test Site as well as efforts to build an unprecedented high-level nuclear waste repository at Yucca Mountain.

Chief Raymond Yowell, of the Western Shoshone National Council, said Western Shoshone are opposed to any further military testing on Shoshone lands.

''This is a direct violation of the CERD finding and an affront to our religious belief [that] mother earth is sacred and should not be harmed. All people who are opposed to these actions by the U.S. should step forward and make their opposition known.''

Rep. Jim Matheson, D-Utah, also questioned the detonation in a letter to Tegnelia.

''Although I understand that this test is not a nuclear test, I am greatly concerned that you have not provided the public with adequate assurances that the test is not being conducted in order to further misguided attempts to build new low-yield nuclear devices,'' Matheson wrote.

The Defense Department's Defense Threat Reduction Agency does not deny that the test was described last year as a planning tool for development of a tactical nuclear weapon.

Earlier, Tegnelia told Agence France Presse that the result of the 700-ton detonation would be a ''mushroom cloud.'' However, he later retracted the statement.

''I don't want to sound glib here but it is the first time in Nevada that you'll see a mushroom cloud over Las Vegas since we stopped testing nuclear weapons.'' Tegnelia also said it would be the ''largest single explosive that we could imagine.''

While the military denies that it is a nuclear test, it will still be many times more powerful than the smallest weapon in the U.S. nuclear stockpile.

The Divine Strake blast will be five times larger than the military's largest conventional weapon, the Massive Ordinance Air Blast Bomb, or MOAB, nicknamed the Mother of All Bombs, according to the Salt Lake Tribune.

Pete Litster, executive director of Shundahai Network, said ongoing weapons tests at the Nevada Test Site violate international law.

''They violate the standing treaty between the U.S. government and the Western Shoshone people. They also violate the spirit of non-proliferation of weapons of mass destruction. The test site is located on Western Shoshone territory, and must not continue to be misused in bold violation of standing agreements between the U.S. government and the Western Shoshone Nation.''

Although approval for the test was sought and obtained from the state of Nevada in January, the test detonation could be cancelled. The Western Shoshone National Council, the Western Shoshone Defense Project and Shundahai Network urged a united effort to halt the detonation.

C Indian Country Today April 17, 2006. All Rights Reserved

Update on Resistance to Divine Strake:

One avenue we are considering is injunctive legal action to stop the Divine Strake test (large scale open air detonation - 700 tons of explosives to be used) from taking place at the Nevada Test Site (on Western Shoshone land). If you want to get involved - We're looking for people who oppose this detonation in the following counties in Utah, Nevada or Arizona:

Those counties are:
Utah - Beaver, Garfield, Iron, Kane, Millard, Piute, San Juan, Sevier, Washington and Wayne. Nevada - Eureka, Lander, White Pine.
Arizona - Apache, Coconino, Gila, Navajo, Yavapai, and the part of Arizona north of the Grand Canyon.

Julie Fishel

Western Shoshone Defense Project
P.O. Box 211308
Crescent Valley, NV 89821
775-468-0230
775-468-0237 (fax)
www.wsdp.org
wsdp@igc.org